A product and process for preparing the product, an all-dairy butter substitute that tastes like butter and has superior spread characteristics when compared to butter, but contains less calories, fat, and sodium, and more protein, calcium, phosphorus and potassium than butter, comprising a homogenized mixture of cream, non-fat dry milk, salt, locust bean gum, lecithin, mono and diglycerides, citric acid, water and natural flavoring formulated for packaging while the mixture is hot, without the need for subsequent agitation to achieve the desired body when the mixture is cooled.