A method for producing allulose crystals, wherein the method comprises cooling and agitating a first admixture comprised of a first portion of allulose syrup and allulose seed crystals and initiating crystallization of allulose dissolved in the allulose syrup, thereby forming a first massecuite comprising allulose crystals and a first mother liquor containing residual dissolved allulose, the cooling and agitating being continued until a first preselected target yield of allulose crystals is achieved.