Methods are provided for manufacturing an internal thread in a porous orthopedic implant, such as an orthopedic anchor. In one embodiment, the internal thread is formed in the orthopedic implant by bonding a pre-formed, internally threaded component to the orthopedic implant. In another embodiment, the internal thread is formed in the orthopedic implant by bonding a solid plug to the orthopedic implant or forming a surface coating on the orthopedic implant and then machining the solid plug or surface coating.