Methods and compositions are provided for modifying the eating behavior of an individual. The compositions provide an oral stimulatory effect such as tingling, cooling, and/or warming. Consumption of the compositions after eating a desired amount of food may habituate the individual to ending a meal and serve to cue cessation of eating, assisting the individual with ending a meal at a time point before a signal of satiety has reached the brain. Consumption of the composition in lieu of snacking between meals may assist the individual with avoiding consumption of snacks.