Disclosed herein are cosmetic compositions for making up and/or coating keratinous fibers, said composition comprising: (a) at least one semicrystalline polymer (b) at least one silicone elastomer blend comprising at least one silicone cross-polymer dispersed in at least one oil (c) at least one hydrophilic gelling agent and (d) an aqueous phase. Also disclosed herein are methods for making up and/or enhancing the appearance of keratinous fibers comprising applying said compositions to the keratinous fibers.