A surgical instrument includes an end effector with a staple cartridge. The end effector and staple cartridge extend along a centerline and have an arcuate portion. The staple cartridge includes a deck and a plurality of staples. The plurality of staples include an outer set of staples and an inner set of staples for respective receipt within outer and inner rows of staple openings formed through the deck. At least one staple of the outer set of staples has an elongated crown relative to the inner set of staples such that the outer set of staples are configured to overlap with the inner set of staples in a direction transverse to the centerline.