The present invention relates to an anhydrous, moldable, cosmetic composition comprising a blend of waxes. The wax blend includes at least four distinct waxes, each characterized by having melting temperatures of from about 60° C. to about 65° C.; from about 33° C. to about 46° C.; from about 88° C. to about 96° C.; and from about 74° C. to about 99° C., respectively. The compositions further include at least one solvent, and a high pigment load. The compositions have excellent feel and payoff characteristics.