Non-toxic, polymeric animal toys with incorporated flavor compositions are disclosed and described. The flavor compositions are emulsified to provide high flash points which will withstand polymer processing techniques used to form the toys without significant losses of the flavor composition. Exemplary animal toys include those with polymeric foam bodies and elastomers that have flavor emulsions mixed into them as well as semi-crystalline polymeric fiber toys in which the outer fibers and all or part of the core fibers have an incorporated flavor composition.
