A pet treat holder and comestible pet treat are disclosed, the pet treat holder including a first member having an opening configured to receive a comestible pet treat, and a cavity in communication with the opening on a lower surface of the first member and configured to receive the comestible pet treat, and wherein the opening is sized such that only a portion the comestible pet treat is accessible from an upper surface of the first member. The comestible pet treat includes an upper portion sized to fit within the opening of the pet treat holder, and a base portion attached to the upper portion, the base portion having a flange, which extends around an outer edge of the base portion and is configured to engage a lower surface of the pet treat holder adjacent to the opening.