An anvil for a surgical stapler. In various arrangements, the anvil comprises an anvil body that is fabricated from a first material and a tip member that is fabricated from a second material that differs from the first material. The tip member may comprise a flexible attachment portion that is configured to be received within an opening in a distal end of the anvil body. A second attachment member is configured to non-removably engage the first flexible attachment portion to bias the first flexible attachment portion into retaining engagement with corresponding portions of the distal end of the anvil body.