Disclosed are apparatus and related methods of producing professional looking and tasting cupcakes. In one embodiment, the disclosed apparatus are novel and pre-made butter cream frosting stickers for standard cupcakes. In a preferred mode of operation, the frosting sticker is applied to the top of a baked cupcake and allowed to set. In one mode of preparation, the sticker is prepared via piping frosting into a disk on a pan and freezing the disk.