Tissue repair kit with one or more scribing tools (10, 50) configured to form in tissue (40) such as cartilage a circular mark (38) having a predetermined diameter; and a cutting template (120) device having first and second portions slidably coupled to one another, to define in a first position a circular cut-out formed therebetween and having a diameter that corresponds to the predetermined diameter, or in an expanded position, an oblong cut-out formed therebetween and having a major axis length that is adjustable.The tissue kit is provided for preparing and implanting tissue scaffolds. The scribing tools mark one or more predetermined shapes around a defect site in tissue. The shape or shapes marked in tissue can be used to cut a tissue scaffold having a shape that matches the shape or shapes marked in tissue. The scribing tool used to mark a shape in tissue can also be used to cut the tissue scaffold.