A multiple day wear composition for keratin surfaces comprising at least one volatile solvent, at least one crosslinked organosiloxane film former, and from about 5 to 12% of montmorillonite minerals comprising a mixture of bentonite and hectorite wherein the ratio of bentonite to hectorite montmorillonite mineral ranges from about 2 to 4 parts of bentonite to 1 part of hectorite and related methods.