A baby bottle holder for use with an infant carrier including a sleeve, configured to hold a baby bottle, a support strap having a width of less than an infant pupillary distance, and a pair of constraining straps each secured to opposite sides of the sleeve. The support strap and pair of constraining straps are attached to the sleeve such that, when linearly extended outwards from the sleeve, they will substantially form one of an inverted letter “T”-shape configuration or inverted letter “Y”-shape configuration, with the stem of the letter being formed by the support strap and the arms of the letter being formed by the constraining straps.