A humeral stem assembly (100) includes a stem portion (104), a metaphyseal portion 108, and an intermediate spacer (112). The stem portion has a stem engagement feature (144) that has a first plurality of teeth (148). The stem engagement feature is located on a superior end of the stem portion. The metaphyseal portion has a metaphyseal engagement feature (184). The metaphyseal engagement feature can include a second plurality of teeth (188). The metaphyseal engagement feature is located on an inferior end of the metaphyseal portion. The intermediate spacer has a first spacer engagement feature (160) and a second spacer engagement feature (168). The first and second spacer engagements have a third plurality of teeth (164) on an inferior end of the intermediate spacer, and a fourth plurality of teeth (172) on a superior end of the intermediate spacer, respectively.