Flavor infused cinnamon sticks and a method for making the same. Natural cinnamon sticks are infused with various flavors, flavor pre-cursors, or other agents such as vitamins, sweeteners, or food colorants. The cinnamon sticks provide a natural matrix for carrying the various flavors or other agents, as well as providing a convenient handheld stirrer when used to add flavor to a beverage. Although ground cinnamon produces an intense amount of cinnamon flavor that would dominate over other infused flavors, the cinnamon flavor in intact cinnamon sticks leaches out only slowly, and thus the cinnamon flavor can harmoniously co-exist with the various infused flavors. Various methods of producing the infused cinnamon sticks are also taught.