A yogurt smoothie kit for use in preparing yogurt smoothies, when combined with mixing liquid, is provided herein. The kit includes a container having an inner volume, an open top end, a closed bottom end, and a demarcation positioned between the top end and the bottom end, the inner volume divided by the demarcation into an upper volume above the demarcation and a lower volume below the demarcation. The kit further includes, inside the container, a plurality of frozen yogurt pellets, the frozen yogurt pellets each having at least milk proteins, milk fat, yogurt bacterial cultures, sugar, and a stabilizer mix.