Embodiments of the present invention provide a system and method for automatic driver evaluation of a persons driving capabilities and render an outcome of pass, fail, or pass with restrictions without the need for a trained observer to evaluate drivers performance. In one embodiment, the automatic driver evaluation system facilitates the display of a predetermined driving route designed for a predetermined demography, observe simulated driving performance of a user on the predetermined driving route, record errors made by the user while performing the simulated drive, and compare the performance errors to at least one threshold value and generate a score based on the comparison.