An animal feed includes a first amount of a plant-based supplement, a second amount of base animal food, and a composition of nutrient additives in an amount and composition calculated according to a modified nutrient profile associated with a mixture of the base animal food with the plant-based supplement at a set ratio of the second amount to the first amount. The plant-based supplement may include cooked pumpkin. Also, the composition of nutrient additives may include selected ones of choline, calcium, taurine, and L-Carnitine.