In a system and method for controlling an implantable stimulator capable of producing pacing pulses to be delivered to cardiac tissue, as well as vagal stimulation pulses to be delivered to vagus nerve sites, upon detection of a premature cardiac event, such as a premature ventricular or atrial contraction, a simulated heart rate turbulence (HRT) procedure is applied if the intrinsic heart rate turbulence is weakened or absent. The simulated HRT includes a first phase in which the heart rate is increased, from the existing level, for a number of heart beats, a second phase in which the heart rate is decreased for a number of heart beats, and an optional third phase in which the heart rate is returned to said existing level.