Antimicrobial skin prep solutions of the invention comprise: a major amount of at least one organic solvent, wherein at least about 80% by weight based on total weight of the solvent comprises at least one fugitive organic solvent; an antimicrobially effective amount of at least one antimicrobial agent; and an amount of at least one adhesive effective to increase adhesion of surgical drapes and medical dressings to skin prepped with the antimicrobial skin prep solution, wherein the at least one adhesive is distinct from the at least one antimicrobial agent and is a liquid at room temperature. Coated substrates, applicators, and related methods are also disclosed.