An anvil for a circular surgical stapler includes an anvil surface and an anvil shaft. The anvil surface defines an inner annular array of staple forming pockets and an outer annular array of staple forming pockets. The inner annular array of staple forming pockets includes a plurality of staple forming pocket pairs. The outer annular array of staple forming pockets also includes a plurality of staple forming pocket pairs. The outer annular array of staple forming pockets is arranged in a mirrored symmetry with the inner annular array of staple forming pockets. The anvil shaft is configured to couple with a stapling head assembly of a surgical stapler.