A method of verifying test data generated by a meter includes testing the sample with the meter. The meter further generates and displays a first analyte level, and calculates and displays a First Verification Value. The method further includes displaying a user interface using a computing system for receiving a user input and receiving the user input including the first analyte level and the First Verification Value. The receiving computing system calculates a Second Verification Value from the entered Result Data. The method further includes verifying with the computing system that the user input was correctly entered by comparing the entered First Verification Value with the calculated Second Verification Value and provides an indication to the user as to whether the user input was correctly entered. The meter may additionally generate additional analyte levels and the Verification Values include the additional analyte levels times corresponding, predetermined multipliers.